Understanding Merchant Underwriting: A Guide for Payment Providers

Merchant underwriting is a vital part of ensuring secure and efficient transactions in payment processing. It’s the process payment provider underwriting teams use to assess the risks involved in onboarding new merchants, ensuring only reliable businesses are able to process payments.

This guide provides a clear overview of the underwriting process, its role in risk management, and how businesses can navigate it effectively. Whether you’re a payment provider, a risk management professional, or a business looking to onboard new merchants, this guide will give you the insight you need to understand and streamline the process.

‍

What is Merchant Underwriting?

Merchant underwriting is a vital part of the payments industry, focusing on determining whether a business is eligible to process electronic payments. The process involves a detailed review of several factors to assess the risk of allowing a business to accept card payments. Key areas include:

• Financial Health: Examining the stability of the business.
• Business Model: Understanding the structure and nature of the business.
• Transaction History: Looking at past transactions to spot any concerning patterns.
• Compliance: Ensuring the business follows relevant industry regulations.
• Security Measures: Assessing the strength of the business’s data protection practices.

Payment provider underwriting teams use this information to evaluate potential risks and ensure businesses are equipped to handle sensitive payment data securely.

Ultimately, merchant underwriting aims to measure the level of risk a merchant presents—not just to the payment provider, but to the broader payment ecosystem. Providers must strike a balance between accepting as many merchants as possible and minimising the risks of fraud, chargebacks, and non-compliance. A thorough merchant risk assessment is essential to achieving this goal, as it provides a comprehensive evaluation of the merchant’s financial health, business model, and compliance status.

In this way, underwriting acts as a form of risk management, safeguarding both the payment provider and the customers. Since businesses differ in structure and operations, underwriting also tailors its assessment to fit the specific type of business—whether it's a high-risk sector like online gambling or a lower-risk one, such as a local coffee shop.

‍

The Role of Underwriting in Payment Processing

Underwriting is crucial in maintaining the efficiency and reliability of payment processing systems. The payments ecosystem relies heavily on trust between merchants, consumers, and payment providers. Without thorough underwriting, this trust can quickly break down, leading to financial losses, reputational harm, and an increased risk of fraud.

A key function of underwriting is identifying high-risk merchants that could jeopardise the payment system. High-risk merchants are typically those operating in sectors more prone to chargebacks or fraudulent activity, such as:

• Online Gambling
• Adult Entertainment
• Subscription-Based Services

By thoroughly vetting these businesses, payment provider underwriting can reduce the risks linked to processing their payments.. A detailed merchant risk assessment is key to this process, as it helps identify high-risk merchants and implement appropriate safeguards. Onboarding high-risk merchants without adequate underwriting leaves providers vulnerable to fraud, excessive chargebacks, and a range of costly problems.

Underwriting also plays a vital role in ensuring compliance with essential industry regulations, including:

• Payment Card Industry Data Security Standard (PCI DSS)
• Anti-Money Laundering (AML) regulations
• Know Your Customer (KYC) procedures

Adhering to these regulations helps to prevent illegal activities, such as money laundering and identity theft, creating a safer, more secure environment for all parties involved.

As part of a broader risk management strategy, underwriting acts as the first line of defence against these potential threats. Without a solid underwriting process, payment providers would have little to no means of preventing fraud or managing the damage caused by risky merchants.

‍

Why is Merchant Account Underwriting Crucial?

Merchant account underwriting is essential in the payment processing industry. It ensures that only businesses capable of handling electronic payments securely are approved. Without it, the system becomes vulnerable to risks like fraud, chargebacks, and regulatory issues, affecting both payment providers and consumers.

Underwriting helps protect payment providers from financial losses, particularly from chargebacks, which occur when customers dispute transactions. By identifying merchants at higher risk of fraud or chargebacks, underwriting reduces the chance of these issues costing payment providers.

It also ensures consumer trust. In 2025’s digital world, customers expect secure payment experiences. By vetting merchants, payment providers ensure that businesses are financially sound and can protect sensitive data, building confidence in the payments industry.

Additionally, underwriting ensures compliance with legal standards, like Anti-Money Laundering (AML) and data protection regulations (e.g., GDPR), helping reduce the risk of fines or legal issues.

Ultimately, underwriting minimises risk, ensures compliance, and supports a stable payments ecosystem, keeping the system secure and efficient.

How Does the Merchant Underwriting Process Work?

The merchant underwriting process typically involves five key steps:

1. Gather Documentation

Payment providers require a range of documents to assess a merchant's risk profile. These may include:

• Business registration documents
• Financial statements
• Tax identification numbers
• Proof of address (e.g., utility bills or lease agreements)

‍

2. Review Application

The payment provider underwriting team reviews the application, considering factors like business type, financial stability, and transaction history. This stage involves a combination of automated checks and manual reviews by underwriting teams.

‍

3. Follow-Up

If more information is needed, the payment provider will request additional documents or clarification. Follow-up is usually triggered by incomplete applications or discrepancies in financial data.

‍

4. Approval

Once the review is complete, the payment provider makes a decision. Approved merchants may face certain restrictions, such as rolling reserves or transaction limits, depending on their risk level.

‍

5. Onboarding and Implementation

The final step involves setting up the merchant account and integrating the payment system. This includes configuring software, training staff, and ensuring compliance with industry standards.

‍

How to Streamline the Underwriting Process?

For a smooth underwriting process ahead of onboarding, merchants should prioritise preparation and transparency. This means having all necessary documentation ready, keeping accurate financial records, and being clear about business operations and transaction history. Here’s how merchants can successfully navigate the underwriting process:

‍

1. Prepare Required Documentation Early: 

• Bank statements (to confirm financial stability)
• Merchant processing statements (to review transaction history)
• Tax documents (to ensure compliance with regulations)
• Business verification documents (such as lease agreements or utility bills)

‍

2. Ensure Your Documentation is Comprehensive:

• Double-check documents for accuracy.
• Provide clear, legible copies.
• Be ready to clarify any discrepancies or unusual patterns.

‍

‍3. Maintain Transparency and Accuracy:

• Be upfront about your business operations and transaction history.
• Keep financial records organised and up-to-date.

‍

By following these steps, merchants can streamline the underwriting process, reduce delays, and set the stage for a smooth onboarding experience.

‍

Key Factors Affecting Merchant Underwriting

The underwriting process for merchants is shaped by several factors that help payment providers assess risk, fraud potential, and compliance issues. Here’s a breakdown of the key elements involved:

‍

1. Types of Products/Services

The nature of what a merchant sells is crucial in underwriting decisions. Certain categories carry higher risk due to their characteristics:

• Digital goods: Often face closer scrutiny because their intangible nature can lead to disputes or chargebacks.
• Subscription services: Regular billing models are carefully examined to ensure compliance and minimise risk of customer disputes.
• High-risk products: Items with high return rates or those susceptible to fraud (e.g., electronics, luxury goods) may face additional underwriting requirements.

‍

2. Industry Risk

Some industries are inherently riskier than others due to higher chargeback rates, regulatory challenges, or reputational concerns. Examples include:

• Gambling: High chargeback rates and strict regulations make this industry particularly challenging.
• Adult entertainment: Regulatory scrutiny and reputational risks often lead to stricter underwriting.
• Cryptocurrency: Volatility and regulatory uncertainty contribute to its classification as high-risk.

‍

According to Forbes, high-risk merchants may face:

• Higher processing fees.
• Stricter underwriting requirements.
• Limited access to certain payment processing solutions.

‍

3. Merchant Location

Geographic factors can significantly impact underwriting decisions. Payment providers consider:

• Fraud rates: Regions with higher instances of fraud may require additional due diligence.
• Economic stability: Merchants in unstable economies may face stricter scrutiny due to the potential for financial instability.
• Regulatory environment: Countries with stringent regulations or sanctions may complicate the underwriting process.

‍

4. Merchant Size

The size of a business can influence the underwriting process in different ways:

• Large businesses: These often undergo more rigorous underwriting due to their high transaction volumes and complex operations.
• Small businesses: While they may have lower transaction volumes, limited financial history or resources can pose challenges during underwriting.

‍

5. Transaction Volume and Size

The scale of a merchant’s transactions is a critical factor in assessing risk:

• High transaction volumes: These increase the perceived risk, as they can lead to greater financial exposure for payment providers.
• Large transaction sizes: High-value transactions may require additional scrutiny to prevent fraud or financial loss.

‍

6. Chargeback Volume

A history of frequent chargebacks is a major red flag during underwriting. Key points to consider:

• Chargeback thresholds: Visa reports that merchants with a chargeback rate above 1% are often flagged as high-risk.
• Impact on underwriting: High chargeback rates can lead to stricter requirements, higher fees, or even the denial of payment processing services.

‍

7. Billing and Credit Policies

Payment providers assess billing practices and credit policies to ensure they align with industry standards and reduce risk:

• Transparency: Clear billing descriptions help avoid disputes.
• Refund policies: Fair, accessible refund processes can reduce chargebacks.
• Compliance: Adherence to regulations is key to minimising risk.

By understanding these factors, merchants can better navigate the underwriting process and proactively address potential issues. For payment providers, these criteria help make informed decisions that balance risk with opportunity.

‍

What Are the 5 Types of Underwriting Checks?

Underwriting checks are an essential part of the merchant onboarding process, ensuring that businesses are legitimate, financially stable, and compliant with regulations. These checks help payment providers reduce risks, such as fraud, chargebacks, and non-compliance. Here's a breakdown of the five key types of underwriting checks and why each one matters.

‍

‍1. Tax ID/Business Name Matching

This check ensures that the merchant's tax identification number (TIN) or equivalent aligns with the registered business name.

• Why it matters: It confirms the legitimacy of the business and helps safeguard against identity theft and fraud.
• How it works: The payment provider cross-checks the provided tax ID with official government or regulatory records to ensure accuracy.
• Outcome: A mismatch may delay onboarding or lead to rejection if the issue isn’t addressed.

‍

2. Business History Check

This check evaluates the merchant’s payment processing history to identify any potential risks.

• Why it matters: It helps assess the reliability and risk level of the business.
• How it works: Payment providers review the merchant’s history for fraud patterns, chargeback rates, and reputation within the industry.
• Outcome: A problematic history may result in higher fees, stricter terms, or even rejection.

‍

3. Bank Account Verification

This check ensures the merchant has an active and valid bank account for payment processing and debt repayment.

• Why it matters: It protects payment providers from the risks of dealing with invalid or fraudulent accounts.
• How it works: Providers confirm the account is in the merchant’s name and capable of processing transactions.
• Outcome: Failure to verify the bank account will halt the onboarding process until resolved.

‍

4. Credit Check

This check assesses the merchant’s financial stability and ability to manage transactions responsibly.

• Why it matters: It allows payment providers to gauge the merchant’s ability to handle financial risks and repay debts.
• How it works: Providers review the merchant’s credit score, history, outstanding debts, and overall financial health.
• Outcome: Poor credit history may lead to higher fees, stricter terms, or rejection.

‍

5. AML Checks (Anti-Money Laundering)

These checks ensure compliance with legal requirements and reduce fraud risks.

• Why it matters: They are legally necessary to prevent money laundering, terrorist financing, and other financial crimes.
• How it works: Providers verify the merchant’s identity, check for illegal activities or high-risk industries, and monitor transactions for suspicious behaviour.
• Outcome: Non-compliance could result in penalties, fines, or termination of the account.

These underwriting checks are vital for building a secure, trustworthy payment system. They help protect both payment providers and consumers by verifying a merchant’s identity, financial standing, and regulatory compliance. While the process may be thorough, it ultimately reduces risk and sets the stage for long-term business relationships.

‍

‍

ISO vs. PayFac: Key Differences and When to Choose Each

When it comes to payment processing, businesses often need to decide whether to partner with an Independent Sales Organisation (ISO) or a Payment Facilitator (PayFac). Both options offer distinct advantages and limitations, and the right choice depends on your business’s unique needs. Below, we break down the key differences and help you decide which one suits your business best.

1. Independent Sales Organisations (ISOs)
ISOs represent a more traditional payment processing model, giving merchants greater control over their accounts. However, this flexibility comes with a more involved setup process. Here’s what to know:

• Account Setup: Merchants apply for their own merchant accounts, which involves a detailed underwriting process. While this can take longer, it allows for a tailored solution.
• Control and Flexibility: ISOs provide more control over payment processing, offering the option to negotiate terms and customise features to suit specific needs.
• Ideal For: Businesses with complex requirements, high-risk industries, or those needing highly customised payment solutions.

‍

2. Payment Facilitators (PayFacs)
PayFacs streamline the payment process by allowing merchants to operate under a master account. This model prioritises speed and simplicity, but may offer less flexibility than an ISO. Key points include:

• Account Setup: Merchants don’t apply for their own accounts; they operate under the PayFac’s master account, which significantly speeds up setup.
• Ease of Use: The PayFac model simplifies the onboarding process, making it ideal for businesses that want to start processing payments quickly.
• Limitations: Merchants have less control over payment processing and may face restrictions on customisation.
• Ideal For: Low-risk businesses, startups, or those who value simplicity and speed over customisation.

‍

Choosing the Right Option

The choice between an ISO and a PayFac depends on factors like your industry, business size, and risk profile. Here’s a breakdown to help you decide:

• Industry Considerations
  
  • High-Risk Industries: For businesses in high-risk sectors like travel, gaming, or CBD, an ISO may be a better choice due to its flexibility and ability to handle complex needs.
  • Low-Risk Industries: PayFacs tend to work well for low-risk businesses like retail or professional services, where simplicity and speed are priorities.

‍

• Business Size and Growth Stage
  
  • Small Businesses and Startups: PayFacs are typically a better fit for smaller businesses or startups that need to get up and running quickly.
  • Established Businesses: Larger or more established businesses may benefit from the greater control and customisation offered by ISOs.

‍

• Risk Profile
  
  • High-Risk Merchants: ISOs are equipped to handle high-risk merchants, offering more tailored underwriting and risk management solutions.
  • Low-Risk Merchants: PayFacs are ideal for low-risk businesses that don’t require extensive customisation.

‍

• Customisation Needs
  
  • If your business requires specific payment features or integrations, an ISO may be the better fit.
  • If speed and simplicity are more important, a PayFac is likely the right choice.

‍

Both ISOs and PayFacs have their place in payment processing. By understanding the key differences and evaluating your business’s needs, you can make an informed decision that aligns with your goals. Whether you prioritise control and customisation (ISO) or simplicity and speed (PayFac), the right choice will help optimise your payment processing and support growth.

‍

Conclusion

Merchant underwriting is a crucial process for payment providers, acting as a key safeguard against fraud, chargebacks, and financial risk. By carefully assessing the risk profile of merchants, payment providers help create a safer, more reliable payment ecosystem. This not only protects the provider but also builds trust with customers and stakeholders.

Underwriting isn’t just a routine task—it’s the foundation of secure and efficient payment processing. By thoroughly vetting merchants, providers protect their operations, safeguard customers, and help maintain a stable payment landscape. For businesses, partnering with providers who prioritise transparency, compliance, and risk management is vital for a smooth onboarding process.

Ultimately, strong underwriting practices benefit everyone, ensuring a safer, more trustworthy payment environment.

‍